Inquiring Deeply Newsletter,
Inquiring Deeply About Praise
The famed German novelist Thomas Mann apparently experienced quite a bit of anxiety about how his work would be received. He quipped that he suffered from a “P vitamin deficiency”: chronic hunger for praise.
I personally resonate with the idea of P vitamin and its implied meaning: that approval fills deep needs and is an essential psychological nutrient. It is quite evident that the need for approval is a driving force in human behavior, as well a basic regulator of self-esteem. We are motivated to be seen in a myriad of different forms. Praise and approval— as well as its close cousins mirroring, recognition, validation, and positive evaluation— are all very high in Vitamin P! Praise is an upper. On the other side of the coin, the failure to receive praise which is wanted, needed, or expected is emotionally upsetting.
So, what is this about? When we look into how the need for praise shows up in our experience, we confirm what Heinz Kohut postulated in psychoanalytic Self Psychology: recognition and approval are self-delineating and life-affirming. We seek validation for who we take ourselves to be and in order to feel a vital connection to our core experience of self. In Buddhist psychology, the primal motivation is thehunger to be; to exist.
When we do not get sufficient Vitamin P from important relational others—when we fail to be affirmed as valuable, special, worthwhile, and/or lovable— our incapacity to sustain a coherent sense of ourselves shows up as emotional turbulence. While each person’s experience is somewhat idiosyncratic, the general tenor is usually anxiety, depression, or similar. What I find in my own experience is a sense of deflation: negative mood and self-critical ideation. The general idea of contraction seems to capture it.
The hunger to be seen is a primal relational desire: the need to exist in the eyes of the Other. This deep relational need stems from the fact that humans need other humans to survive. To be abandoned as a helpless baby means certain death. Psychological survival, too, depends on being seen. This reality was dramatized in the classic novel of the late 80’s, “Clan Of The Cave Bear”, in which a female character was psychologically exiled for nonconformity to the tribal rules of her Neanderthal brethren. No one was to make eye contact with her. This was a brutal form of punishment.
Self is brought into being in relationship. The prototypical moment is the one that occurs in the first moments after birth, when the new baby looks into the eyes of a mother who is looking back. As Kohut put it, the self at birth is a virtual self, a self which develops in the process of being seen and responded to by(m)other. This is true in earliest psychological life and remains so throughout the life span. What is not validated by others will tend to be repressed or will simply fail to come into being. In other words, if we are not seen, we cannot be fully alive.
So, the wish to be seen is quite understandable. But how can we understand thefear of being seen? In psychological terms, we find at its core the fear that we are not worthy of being seen. In Buddhist terms, this too is connected to a fear of non-being.
Our fear of being invisible connects both to our elemental fear of death and of existential emptiness. The fear of not being seen joins together with the fear of being alone. This can become a futile quest to fill our empty places with other people.
So it is useful to inquire deeply into both the wish and fear of being seen. We need to find within our own experience all the ways that, directly and indirectly, we seek P vitamin; all the constructive as well as dysfunctional ways we seek attention and approval. A compelling example from contemporary life is how people relate to getting “likes” on social media, which can assume the proportions of an actual addiction! According to some, ‘thumbs up’ stimulates little bursts of dopamine in the brain. (Maybe that is Vitamin P!)
In any event, when we inquire deeply, what we can also find is that recognition is not love. Our deepest desire is not for praise or approval, but for connection with others.
* Mindfulness-Informed Relational Psychotherapy and Psychoanalysis: Inquiring Deeply
Routledge Press, 2017. https://www.amazon.com/-/e/B01N24V17T
On October 9th and 11th, I will be leading the meeting of One Dharma Sangha in Santa Barbara: Guided meditation & dharma talk on “What is a “self” and what is it for?”
Tuesday 10/09/18, 6:00-7:00 p.m. @ MacVeagh House, Museum of Natural History; 2559 Puesta Del Sol, Santa Barbara, CA 93105
Thursday 10/11/18, 6:00-7:00 [email protected] “Sacred Space” in Summerland; 2594 Lillie Ave, Summerland, CA 93067